The Numbers Game: Can Thomas Tuchel’s Bold Squad Decisions Deliver for England?

Thomas Tuchel on the sidelines during England’s World Cup qualifier

England finally found their rhythm under Thomas Tuchel last month, producing a stunning 5-0 victory over Serbia in World Cup qualifying. It was a statement win after an unconvincing 1-0 result against Andorra at Villa Park.

Whether Tuchel loosened his tactical reins or the players took it upon themselves to perform, England displayed a level of quality rarely seen so far under the German coach.

Noni Madueke, Ezri Konsa, and Marc Guehi all scored their first international goals in the Serbia win — marking just the third time since 1966 that England had three or more debut scorers in one match.

Selection Controversies Ahead of Wales Clash

Tuchel’s latest England squad, however, has sparked debate. Ahead of friendlies against Wales and a qualifier with Latvia, the omission of Jude Bellingham, Phil Foden, Jack Grealish, and Adam Wharton has raised eyebrows.

Despite being fit, Bellingham and Foden were left out, while Grealish — currently the Premier League’s top chance creator — and Palace’s rising star Wharton also missed the cut.

Tuchel still boasts a talent-rich lineup, with Wales boss Craig Bellamy calling England’s depth “ridiculous.” But fans expect consistency following the Serbia win, even as Tuchel experiments with his options at Wembley.

A Tough Test Against Wales

England will face Wales for the first time since their 3-0 triumph at the 2022 World Cup. The Three Lions have dominated this fixture historically, winning seven consecutive meetings.

Opta’s supercomputer gives England a 70.9% chance of victory, with Wales at 12.6% and a draw at 16.5%. Wales’ last win on English soil came in 1977 — nearly half a century ago.

Tuchel’s Gamble and Key Absences

England’s form under Tuchel has been impressive — eight consecutive competitive wins and goals in 16 straight matches. Yet his decision to omit star names remains controversial.

Madueke, one of Tuchel’s best performers, is sidelined with injury, while Bukayo Saka returns to the squad. Grealish, who leads the Premier League in assists and expected assists (xA), was again overlooked despite excellent form.

Tuchel instead favors midfielders like Elliot Anderson and Jordan Henderson, both of whom bring creativity and leadership. Henderson’s experience, in particular, remains vital to the squad’s balance.

Wales’ Challenge

Wales have lost two of their last three games, after previously going 19 unbeaten. They haven’t scored in their last 10 away friendlies and face an England side with strong historical dominance.

Still, England’s recent defeats to Iceland and Senegal in non-competitive matches may offer Bellamy’s side a glimmer of hope.

Players to Watch

England – Harry Kane
The Bayern Munich striker is in sensational form, with 18 goals already this season. He recently became England’s fifth most-capped player and continues to lead by example under Tuchel.

Wales – Brennan Johnson
The Tottenham forward remains Wales’ main attacking threat. Though he’s scored just twice this season, his pace and energy could trouble England’s defense at Wembley.

Final Thoughts

Tuchel’s England reign has shown both brilliance and bold decision-making. His latest selections may define how his philosophy shapes the team ahead of the 2026 World Cup — but only time will tell if his calculated risks truly pay off.

More From Author

Thomas Tuchel’s Relationship With Jude Bellingham Could Shape England’s World Cup Hopes

Mohamed Salah Becomes First African to Score 20 Goals in World Cup Qualifiers