The subtle signs Jim Nill’s dominant era in Dallas is quietly winding down originally appeared on The Sporting News.
Add The Sporting News as a Preferred Source by clicking here.
For three straight seasons, Jim Nill was the best executive in hockey, at least according to his peers.
Dallas Stars General Manager has won the Jim Gregory General Manager of the Year Award three times. He achieved this in three consecutive seasons: 2022–23, 2023–24, and 2024–25, making him the first three-time recipient and the first to win in three consecutive years.
Plus, the team also made the Western Conference Final each of those three years. It seemed like they were locked in at the top of the league’s food chain. But this season, they lost that grip a bit early.
Nill will not be winning the Jim Gregory Award for a fourth straight season. This year’s finalists are Bill Guerin of the Minnesota Wild, Chris MacFarland of the Colorado Avalanche, and Pat Verbeek of the Anaheim Ducks.
Finalists for 2026 Jim Gregory GM of the Year Award, as voted by their peers as well as league executives and selected media following Round 1: Bill Guerin (MIN), Chris MacFarland (COL) and Pat Verbeek (ANA). pic.twitter.com/F3i21zy17P
— Frank Seravalli (@frank_seravalli) May 12, 2026
The dip likely followed the Stars’ early playoff exit. Dallas finished the regular season 50-20-12, marking their third straight 50-win year. However, they blew a 2-1 series lead and lost to Minnesota in six games, ending their streak of three consecutive Western Conference Final appearances.
“We have high expectations here and we didn’t fulfill that,” Nill said following the disappointing run, per NHL. “It’s frustrating. It was probably one of the most demanding seasons I’ve ever gone through, scheduling, travel and for us, injuries… We had a heck of a season. 50 wins, top 10 in all categories, and to sit here now and say we lost in the first round is disappointing.”
He also put a sharper point on the playoff performance itself, saying the Wild “needed” to win, while the Stars just “wanted” to win. That’s a candid admission from a GM about his own team’s mentality.
On the ice, the numbers backed up the disappointment. Dallas managed just three 5-on-5 goals across the six games. Forward Mikko Rantanen’s key injury also gave them a hard time.
He tore his MCL at the 2026 Winter Olympics, missing 15 games. He returned on March 28 for the final 10 regular-season matches but struggled to find his form.
Despite the early exit, Nill’s record is pretty solid. Since he became general manager in 2013, the Stars have achieved 63 playoff wins, which is the second-most in the NHL and reached the 2020 Stanley Cup Final.
Because of the solid track record, Dallas signed Nill to a two-year contract extension on March 31. Owner Tom Gaglardi stated that Nill’s roster management keeps the team competitive. The extension gives Nill the time to pursue a Stanley Cup, which remains the only missing piece of his legacy.
More NHL news:
- Maple Leafs winning lottery doesn’t mean what you think for Auston Matthews
- Alex Tuch’s disappearing act has Sabres on brink before $11 million decision
- Canucks may have gotten 2004-level historically unlucky
- Flames’ trade offer for Nathan MacKinnon is informative for Maple Leafs
- How Zach Benson is Buffalo’s perfect ‘rat’